Concerns Surround Hulu’s The Secret Life of Mormon Wives Amid Domestic Investigation
During a recent meeting with ABC executives, the cast of Hulu’s The Secret Life of Mormon Mrs. raised serious concerns regarding the show’s future amid allegations involving cast member Taylor Frankie Paul. Audio obtained by NBC News reveals that the discussions took place during a nearly 30-minute Zoom call on March 7, following a troubling incident involving Paul and her partner, Dakota Mortensen.
Ongoing Domestic Assault Investigation Fuels Uncertainty
A spokesperson from the Draper, Utah Police Department confirmed this week that an open investigation into domestic assault allegations concerning Paul and Mortensen has been active since February. During the March meeting, the cast expressed apprehension about their careers and the overall reputation of the show in light of these developments.
Legal Troubles Intensify Cast Tensions
Paul’s legal issues escalated in 2023 when she was charged with assault in the presence of a child, criminal mischief, and domestic violence. These charges stemmed from a separate domestic dispute that influenced the storyline of Season 1 of Mormon Wives. Court records indicate that Paul accepted a deferred charge of aggravated assault in August 2025, resulting in the dismissal of four other charges.
Cast Members Voice Reluctance to Continue Filming
One cast member expressed reservations about participating in filming while Paul is under investigation, highlighting the distressing nature of the situation. Statements to ABC executives categorized the scenario as both dangerous and tragic, revealing the conflict between personal friendships and professional obligations within the cast.
Production Company Responds to Safety Concerns
According to a source close to the situation, the primary goal of the March Zoom call was to ensure the cast felt safe and unpressured to continue filming. The production company has hired a seasoned law firm to investigate the conflicting allegations between Taylor and Dakota, underscoring the seriousness of the matter.
Controversial Video Adds to Tensions
On March 7, executives were made aware of troubling video footage allegedly depicting Paul engaging in abusive behavior toward Mortensen, further amplifying concerns within the cast. Several members described the content as harrowing, yet there was hesitation to discuss its details or share the video during the meeting, reinforcing anxieties around the optics of the situation.
Disney’s Decision to Halt Production
In response to these alarming developments, ABC made the decision to cancel the upcoming season of The Bachelorette that was set to feature Paul. A Disney representative stated that the decision was made in light of the newly surfaced video, emphasizing the company’s commitment to familial support amid the turmoil.
Ongoing Investigations and Future Implications
With allegations being investigated by multiple authorities, including the West Jordan Police Department, the situation continues to evolve. A department representative confirmed they had received a domestic violence complaint concerning Paul but did not disclose specific details. As inquiries unfold, a degree of uncertainty looms over the production of Mormon Wives, impacting not just the show but also the personal wellbeing of its cast members.
