Prosecutors Decline to Charge Taylor Frankie Paul in Domestic Violence Case
Utah prosecutors have opted not to pursue charges against Taylor Frankie Paul, a star of “Mormon Wife Secrets,” following domestic violence allegations. The decision was made by the Salt Lake County District Attorney’s Office, which cited insufficient evidence to support a case against Paul.
According to police reports, Paul was under investigation for alleged domestic violence incidents involving her ex-girlfriend, Dakota Mortensen. The district attorney’s office stated that some of the misdemeanor offenses in question occurred over two years ago, thus falling outside the statute of limitations.
The ongoing cases, which are still within the limits of prosecution, also did not meet the criteria typically required for criminal charges. Prosecutors further noted that some allegations were not substantiated by credible evidence.
The statement from the agency emphasized, “The remaining cases lack sufficient evidence to support criminal charges, and the state must be able to prove such allegations beyond a reasonable doubt.”
Interestingly, Paul has made counter-allegations of domestic violence against Mortensen. Both individuals are currently subjects of at least two domestic violence investigations in Utah.
Last month, a spokesperson for the Draper Police Department confirmed that a 2024 incident involving both parties has led to charges and an ongoing domestic violence investigation. Court records reveal that Mortensen and Paul have sought temporary protective orders against each other, highlighting the instability of their relationship. Paul has three children, including one shared with Mortensen.
Upcoming reality show “The Secret Lives of Mormon Wives,” set to premiere in 2024, will explore the turbulent relationship between Paul and Mortensen. Court documents also indicate that Paul pled guilty to one charge of aggravated assault related to a 2023 incident while other charges were dismissed. Body camera footage from this arrest has made its way into the series, capturing ongoing tensions in their lives.
Moreover, Mortensen is facing domestic violence charges linked to incidents involving Paul that occurred in 2024 and May 2025. As of February, both parties have reported additional allegations of domestic violence against each other to the police.
The tumultuous relationship has reportedly influenced the production of “Mormon Wife Secrets,” resulting in a hiatus last month due to the continuing investigations into domestic violence claims. Cast members raised alarm about the show’s viability if Paul remained in the project. Additionally, her scheduled appearance on the new season of The Bachelorette was canceled following the circulation of a leaked video tied to the earlier incident. Sources have confirmed to NBC News that Mortensen will be excluded from the upcoming season of “Vanderpump Villa.”
