Casemiro’s Remarkable Season Defies Pundits’ Criticism
Two years ago, Jamie Carragher delivered a rather blunt piece of advice to Brazilian midfielder Casemiro: “Quit football before you quit football.” Fast forward to the current season, and Casemiro has proven his critics wrong with a commendable performance for Manchester United, amassing nine goals—second only to Benjamin Sesco—alongside two assists. He has started 31 of 32 games and logged an impressive 2,417 minutes on the pitch, appearing in 13 matches, including seven of the last nine.
Fan Appeal for Casemiro to Remain at United
The announcement in January regarding Casemiro’s impending departure from United at the end of the season drew impassioned pleas from fans eager for the 34-year-old midfielder to stay. His resurgence as a first-choice player in the national team’s midfield heading into the World Cup further underscores his enduring value on the field.
Critiques and Character Shines Through
Casemiro’s recent resurgence contrasts sharply with earlier criticisms from pundits who suggested he consider retirement. Carragher, particularly vocal after United’s 4-0 defeat to Crystal Palace in May 2024, remarked that Casemiro “must know tonight that he only has three games left at the top level.” Yet, the Brazilian’s strong character and work ethic have silenced many critics, reaffirming his worth to the team.
The Controversial Transfer Landscape
During Erik ten Hag’s tenure, United contemplated selling Casemiro, who earns nearly £365,000 a week under a four-year contract. Previously, co-owner Sir Jim Ratcliffe had called the midfielder a questionable acquisition. This led to an unexpected turn in January 2025, when Casemiro found himself on the bench during crucial league matches, as Ten Hag’s successor, Ruben Amorim, opted for Toby Collier instead.
Revival under Amorim and Europa League Success
Amorim’s shift in strategy saw a renewed focus on the Europa League, where Casemiro played pivotal roles in victories against Real Sociedad, Lyon, and Athletic Bilbao. His contributions in these critical matches have made him an essential asset to the team, changing the narrative around his fitness and ability to compete at an elite level.
Managerial Insight and Player Development
Amorim’s acknowledgment of Casemiro’s talent marked a significant turnaround. He commented, “Initially he was inferior to all the midfielders… but he fought and worked and now he is back in the national team.” This reflects not just personal growth for Casemiro but also a broader coaching philosophy that values experience and resilience in players as they age.
Factors Influencing Performance in Mid-30s
The question of why players like Casemiro excel in their mid-30s can be attributed to improved fitness and a more cohesive team dynamic under manager Michael Carrick. As a former player in a similar role, Carrick understands the nuances of older players’ contributions, providing an environment where their experience can flourish without the reliance on raw physicality.
The Future of Casemiro at Manchester United
After United’s recent 2-1 victory against Brentford, Carrick indicated that Casemiro is unlikely to alter his decision to leave at the end of the season. This decision appears prudent as he nears his 35th birthday, serving as a clear reminder of the transient nature of elite football. Whether he continues his career elsewhere, possibly in Major League Soccer or Saudi Arabia, remains to be seen.
